One of the guys at work needs to replace a high end frame and has been round asking about the difference between carbon fibre and titanium as frame materials - specifically he is interested in what the ride difference is between the two materials. Any answers, either email me or comment here (if you can remember your username and password, Andy) ;-)
As most of you know, my experience is only of Reynolds 531!
Thanks.
Lisa
Lisa…
ReplyDeleteIn a nut shell…
Carbon fibre is now the predominant material choice for building competition racing frames. There are many reasons for this but essentially if you want the optimum combination of strength, light weight, and comfort then it is hard to beat. Careful frame design and use of the fibres can create stiffness where required and compliance where desirable. Not all carbon fibre is created equal however and it really is worth pointing out that you do pretty much get what you pay for! Don’t be fooled by appearances as most carbon frames are wrapped with a final layer to make a frame more aesthetically pleasing, much like MDF furniture has a veneer added to make it look like something it isn’t…
If crashed Carbon fibre will have a tendency to shatter as it does not cope well with impact and is impossible to repair cost effectively unless a lugged construction method is employed such as on a Colnago.
Titanium does however have its uses. Generally a Ti frame will feel a little “softer” and less direct, in fact, more like a steel frame. It is however very robust and has an almost indefinite lifespan. If built “light” then titanium has a reputation for being “whippy” and giving a less direct response to rider input. If built stiff it will nearly always weigh more than a carbon fibre counterpart.
In short if your friend is racing Carbon is where it’s at.. If he’s is more interested in leisure rides and sportives ands hence travels a lot Ti is worth a look but Carbon is where I would, and perhaps more importantly have put MY money .
One final note is that if the frame chosen does not fit well the material chosen makes little difference. If he is miles away from Box hill then maybe seek out a reputable local shop. Having said that, if he is serious and wants to do things properly he should probably get in touch with me and make the journey anyway…
He can call me on 01737 844576 if he would like to discuss anything further.
Regards
Rohan